Different approaches nowadays are used by the companies to systematically compare and evaluate logistics service providers. The purpose of this study is to classify and critically evaluate methods applied to select logistics service providers. This study is organized as follows. Foremost, a systematic literature review was conducted to learn what evaluation methods are applied and how these methods are categorized. Highly ranked literature reviews related to third-party logistics selection problems and multi-criteria decision-making approaches for supplier evaluation and selection were chosen to learn how evaluation methods are categorized by industry leading experts. Second literature review discovered 42 different methods, various combinations of methods and approaches used for the purpose of selection of logistics service provider it was discovered that selection of logistics service provider is classified as multiple criteria decision-making problem. Selection of logistics service provider is a complex process that is often divided into several sub-processes. Each sub-process may require application of individual method. Single methods are not always sufficient to provide solution in scope of the sub-process, hence, combination of methods is often used.