The increasing demand for sustainable materials and circular economy has driven significant research into the recycling and the reuse of carbon fibers. Recycled carbon fiber (rCF) reinforced polymers (rCFRP) offer a promising solution by utilizing short rCF to create high-performance composites at a reduced cost compared to polymers reinforced with virgin carbon fibers (vCF). Currently, as a consequence of the recycling processes used by the industry, long and continuous carbon fibers from manufacturing waste and structures reaching end-of-life become short, recycled fibers. These rCF still possess rather high mechanical properties which however, are slightly lower than properties of vCF [1]. This study aims to show potential of using these discontinuous rCF to design high performance sustainable composites by combining rCF with vCF and/or other reinforcements to produce hybrid composites. To achieve this, the traditional paper-making technique is adapted to manufacture non-woven mats out of short rCF, vCF, and a combination of both. The fibers used in this study have an average length of 12 mm. Mats are produced one at a time by mechanically dispersing the fibers in a container with a solution of water and binding agent, and with the aid of a stirrer. This process promotes the opening of the fiber bundles and transforms them into a network of two-dimensional “dandelion” like architecture.